The Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled on the Blizzard
We previously prepared an advisory
on the District Court decision.
The DMCA claims related to whether Glider violates DMCA sections 1201(a)(2) and (b)(1) by circumventing WOW's Warden, which is intended to detect bots. The Court ruled in Blizzard's favor with respect to "dynamic non-literal elements" of WOW.
In reaching its decision, the Court refused to follow a Federal Circuit decision (in the Chamberlain
case) interpreting the DMCA. The 9th Circuit ruled that Section 1201 (a) creates a new
anti-circumvention right distinct from copyright infringement while section (b) strengthens the traditional prohibition against copyright infringement. In contrast, the Federal Circuit in Chamberlain found that the DMCA coverage is limited to a copyright owner's rights under Section 106 of the Copyright Act, and required a "nexus" to infringement. The 9th Circuit refused to adopt any requirement for an infringement nexus. The tension between these appeals courts may set up a show down in the Supreme Court.
The Court went on to find that MDY did violate Section 1202 (a)(2) of the DMCA with respect to the dynamic non-literal elements of WOW. But the Court found that Glider does not violate DMCA Section 1201(a)(2) with respect to WOW's literal and individual non-literal elements, because Warden does not effectively control access to these WOW elements.
The Court also found that the tortious interference with contract claims were not preempted by the Copyright Act, but that factual issues prevented a proper summary judgment finding. As a result, it vacated the district court's summary judgment ruling on this issue and remanded the issue of personal liability for MDY's CEO.
Perhaps serendipitously, the decision was handed down just days after Blizzard's release of
Cataclysm the third expansion of WOW. More than 3.3 million
copies as of Cataclysm were sold in the first 24 hours of release, which according to Blizzard, makes it the
fastest-selling PC game of all time.
Here is a copy of the 9th Circuit decision